In the book Sunday Nights at Seven, Jack relates what happened as he recalled it. He was convinced by his lawyer, Bill Donovan, to change his plea to “guilty.” So that’s what he did. Donovan, incidentally doesn’t appear to have been in court the day it happened.
Here is the Associated Press story on what happened in court that day. The judge must have known in advance the change was going to happen; it’s unlikely he would have pronounced a sentence on the same day otherwise. To be honest, the judge was being a jerk. There was no need to bully and humiliate Jack Benny in court. The judge starts off by saying it was easy for him to be victimised by a smooth-talker, then immediately turns around and says he shouldn’t have been. The judge knew his comments would make the front page, so he used his spotlight for all it was worth.
This version of the AP story appeared on the front page of Wisconsin’s Rhinelander Daily News.
Jack Benny Is Fined $ 10,000, Placed on Probation for Year
Radio Comedian Pleads Guilty to Smuggling Charge in U. S. Court.
______
Admits His Shame
______
Usually Gay Radio Star Is Nervous, Somewhat Timid in Courtroom.
George Burns, also a famous radio and stage comedian, pleaded guilty to virtually the same charges Dec. 12. He was fined $8,000 and given a suspended sentence of one year and a day.
Albert N. Chaperau, a co-defendant with Burns as well as in the indictment against Benny, pleaded guilty to both charges and is still awaiting sentence. Both Benny and Burns purchased jewelry which he had brought into the country.
No Actual Smuggling.
The government at no time contended the two comedians had actually done any smuggling.
Benny's New York attorney, Carl E. Newton, approached the bench when court convened. He looked at Judge Vincent L. Leibell and said:
“The defendant asks permission to change his plea.”
The judge glanced down at him and at Benny, who was waiting nervously.
“Is this the defendant?” he asked.
“Yes, sir,” replied Newton, indicating Benny.
The comedian was wearing a natty brown suit and wine-colored tie.
“How do you plead?” asked Judge Leibell.
“Guilty,” said Hollywood’s famous voice in loud tones.
“To all three counts of the indictment?”
“Yes, sir.”
The courtroom was packed with an estimated 400 spectators, mostly admirers of the wise-cracking radio and screen comedian, with standees lining the wall at the back of the room.
Benny’s face today was sober in contrast to the airy grins with which he faced the grand jury at the time of his appearance during the investigation.
Benny’s council, Carl E. Newton, attempted to address the court in the comedian’s behalf after U. S. Attorney John T. Cahill had outlined the indictment, but Judge Leibell shut him off.
“I don’t want to know anything about that,” the judge said. “If you can tell me the circumstances surrounding Benny’s acquaintanceship with Chaperau and any extenuating circumstances in regard to it, I would be glad to listen.”
Many Women in Court.
Sprinkled in the packed courtroom were expensively-dressed women, wearing mink coats.
Throughout the proceedings, the usually self-assured comedian appeared timid and at times his voice was low. Occasionally he smoothed his grey hair and fingered his necktie.
Newton began his explanation as Judge Leibell had suggested.
Benny and Miss Livingstone, he said, met Chaperau casually in Hollywood in the summer of 1937. Mr. and Mrs. Benny went to Europe, and in Paris, Newton said, Benny bought two diamond-studded gold clips and a diamond-studded gold bracelet with a total value of $2,131.
They then went to Cannes and were at breakfast one morning when Chaperau greeted them and renewed his acquaintanceship. As they were leaving Cannes for the north of France and their ship back to the United States, Chaperau boarded the train and suggested that Benny give him the jewelry as he could bring it in duty-free.
Benny and his wife arrived in New York on Aug. 30, 1937, and Chaperau followed on October 7 with the jewelry.
“Somewhere on his person he secreted the jewelry which got past the customs,” defense counsel said.
“During October,” he continued, “Chaperau turned the jewelry over to Benny through a third person. On Jan. 10, 1939, Benny voluntarily turned the jewelry over to the United States and assisted the government by appearing before the grand jury.
“He has no criminal record. He is 45 years of age, a born American citizen, lives with his wife and adopted child in Beverly Hills, and by occupation is an actor and radio comedian.
Judge Leibell asked what the duty would have been on the smuggled articles, and was informed that it would have amounted to about $700. The court, addressing Benny, then declared:
“Sometimes men who are prominent in pictures and radio are just easy marks for smart people. But you should have been smart enough not to have fallen in with such a plan.
"You have undoubtedly made a fortune and shouldn’t have fallen in with a scheme to defraud the United States government and the country in which you acquired your prominence and wealth. It was small stuff.
“If I thought you really planned to do so and it was your own suggestion, I would take a very different view of the case.
‘Stupid Play’.
“Every shrewd person seeks out those who are prominent and you are in a position today you perhaps thought you would never occupy. It is a bitter end to a stupid play.”
Judge Leibell continued:
“I doubt that men such as Benny are to be envied. He is going to pay a heavy fine. He must realize he cannot do these things. I do not think, however, a jail sentence would serve the ends of justice, but the lesson must be such as to bring home to him and to all others that they must be constantly on guard and play fair with their government.”
Judge Leibell then turned to Benny and said:
“You must feel very much ashamed of yourself standing here today. It is a very poor return from you to your government and to all people who have made so much of you.”
Benny stood with downcast eyes, a forlorn figure, and replaced in a voice that was scarcely audible.
“I am ashamed.”
Judge then pronounced sentence and ordered Benny to report at two-week intervals to the probation officer of the federal district court in Los Angeles for one year.
Sunday Nights at Seven reveals one veiled reference to the case was made on the Benny radio show. The premise was that Jack was hunting with Phil Harris when a deadly rattlesnake began to hiss. Benny asked the snake to please go away because he was in enough trouble already. The snake slithered away.
But that wasn’t the end of it. Chaperau had the audacity to sue the Bennys and Burnses. The case wrapped up in 1945.
Suit Is Dismissed
NEW YORK, March 22. (AP)—Supreme Court Justice Ernest E. L. Hammer today dismissed a suit for $7,682, brought against entertainers Jack Benny, Mary Livingston, George Bums and Gracie Allen.
The suit was instituted by Albert N. Chaperau, who was fined that amount by the government in 1943 [sic] for failure to declare jewelry brought from abroad. Chaperau sued the entertainers on grounds that he was acting as bailee for them when he brought the jewelry into the country.
About the same time, we find him co-producing a comedy called “Make Yourself at Home” at the Barrymore Theater on 47th Street that was panned by the New York Sun and the Brooklyn Daily Eagle. There was no mention of his career as a convicted smuggler.
The only future reference I can find to Chaperau after this is on a passenger manifest for an Air France flight to New York of March 31, 1954. The manifest states he was en route to Miami. Next to Chaperau’s name is a hand-written notation: “Det. and Deport.” We can only presume he was arrested and kicked out of the country, despite being born in Philadelphia. By then, Chaperau and the smuggling case were long forgotten. Jack Benny was still a star.
.png)
Không có nhận xét nào:
Đăng nhận xét